Skip to main content
Get Started
Getting recommended5 min readUpdated 2026-11-22

How ChatGPT and Gemini decide which local businesses to recommend

The four things AI assistants check before they recommend a local business, why your own ChatGPT tests mislead you, and a 30-minute plan to get named.

When a homeowner types "best roofers in Austin" into Google, they get ten links, some ads and a map. When they ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Grok the same thing, they get three to five business names and a sentence on why each one is a good fit.

Most people call one of those names. If yours isn't there, you never get the chance to compete on price, reviews or service.

The four things AI checks

AI assistants search the web before they answer, then pick the businesses they feel most sure about. Four things shape that choice:

  1. What the web says about you. ChatGPT leans on web results and Google Business Profiles, plus Bing. Gemini uses Google Search directly. Perplexity and Grok pull from review sites, directories and local articles.
  2. Whether other sites agree. AI is more confident when Yelp, the BBB, Angi, Thumbtack, Nextdoor and trade directories all show the same name, phone, address and a good reputation.
  3. Whether it can read your website. If your site blocks AI assistants, hides your services behind a slow or empty page, or says very little, AI can't confirm what you do or where you work.
  4. How clearly your facts are written. A clear list of services and service areas, the same contact details everywhere, and business details written in a format AI reads directly all remove the guesswork.

The questions that matter most

Many owners test AI by asking "Is [my company] any good?". That tells you about your reputation, but new customers don't know your name yet. They ask questions like:

  • "Who are the best emergency plumbers in Austin, TX?"
  • "Which family dentist near me has fair prices and good reviews?"
  • "Who should I call for hail damage on my roof in Round Rock?"

That's why your AI visibility score in TUSKOS only counts questions that don't mention your name. Questions about you by name are shown separately, so they can't make the score look better than it is.

Why your own ChatGPT tests mislead you

Checking ChatGPT or Gemini from your own phone gives you a skewed picture:

  • It remembers you. Past chats and saved memory can nudge it toward your business.
  • It knows where you are. Your exact location changes local results street by street.
  • It changes its mind. The order of names shifts from one try to the next.

Asking every assistant fresh, the way a stranger would, gives you a starting point you can actually track week to week.

A 30-minute plan

  1. Make sure AI can read your website. Check that your site isn't blocking ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or the other main assistants. Our guide on AI access settings shows you how.
  2. Fix your most important listings. Make sure your name, address, phone and service areas match exactly on Google Business Profile, Bing Places, Yelp and the BBB.
  3. Give AI your facts in its own format. Add an AI summary file and business details for AI, using only facts already on your website.
  4. Check again once the fixes are live. Run another audit in TUSKOS, or turn on regular checks, to see whether AI starts naming you.